Second Constitution
   

Three years after the American Consitution,
there was a Second Constitution



News Worth Mentioning

Latest News

News from Europe

Science Tech Med News

Climate Change News

Second Amendment News

Socialism News

Mauldin City News

Posts on Twitter

Political Cartoons

News Archive
  2020 Jan.-Apr.
  2019 Jan.-Jun.,
Jul.-Dec.
  2018 Jan.-Jun.,
Jul.-Dec.
  2017 Jan. 1-20,
Jan. 21-Dec.
  2016 Post-Election,
Pre-Election



privacy search engine

Friends dont't let
friends get tracked




News Sources
Worth Mentioning


Aerospace and Defense Technology

Americans for Limited Government

AP News

Asia Times

Astronomy & Astrophysics

Aviation Week &
Space Technology


The Ayn Rand Institute
The New Ideal

Babylon Bee (satire)

BBC News

Bearing Arms

BGR

Big League Politics

The BL

Black Community News

The Blaze

Breitbart

Campus Reform

Canada Free Press

Capitalism Magazine

Center for Disease Control

Center for Individualism

CNBC

CNBC Premarket

Comically Incorrect

Conservative Review

Conservative Treehouse

The Conversation
Academic rigor, journalistic flair


Crime Prevention Research Center

C-Span

Daily Caller

Daily Torch — cartoons

Daily Wire

The Dan Bongino Show

Diamond and Silk

Dilbert

The Drive

Drudge Report

Dr. Michael Hurd

The Epoch Times

Express (Britain)

Fact Check

The Federalist

FitsNews

Flyover Culture

Forbes

Foreign Policy

Foundation for
Economic Education


Fox News
Fox Business

France24

Freedom Headlines

FreedomWire

Frontpage Mag - David Horowitz Freedom Center

The Future of Capitalism

The Gateway Pundit

Greenville Symphony Orchestra

Greenwich Mean Time

Gregg Jarett

Herald Mail Media

The Heritage Foundation

The Hill

House of Sunny Podcast

House Freedom Fund news

HumanProgress

Imgur

Imprimis

Independent Journal Review

Infowars

Irish Central Newsletter

JoNova

Judicial Watch

KitCo Gold & Silver

Law Enforcement Today

Legal Insurrection
Branco political cartoons

Lifezette

MAGA Daily Report

Market Watch

McClatchy DC

Michelle Malkin

Military Times

mrc News Busters

NASA News
NASA Spaceflight History


NASDAQ

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

The National Pulse

National Review

Nature

The New Ideal

New York Post

NewsMax

NewsPunch

The NOQ Report

NRA-ILA Legal & Legislative News

The Observer

One America News Network

Pacific Legal Foundation
Newsroom

Patriot Network

Patriot Post

PJ Media

The Pluralist

Political Geography Now

Politico

PoliticsHome (Britain)

Polizette

Red State

The Register

ResearchGate

Rush Limbaugh

Science

Science Alert

Second Amendment Foundation

Seeking Alpha

Senate Conservative Fund news

Simpsonville Sentinel

Sloan Kettering
Cancer Center News


Stand for America

Stat Medical News

Stilton's Place

Thomson Reuters Foundation

Townhall

Trending Views

True Pundit

Trump Transition Website

Trump's accomplishments

Trump's policy positions

Truth Finder
Public Records Search


Turning Point USA



Victims of Socialism

Visual Capitalist

Washington Examiner

Washington Free Beacon

The Wealthiest Investor

Western Journalism

Whatfinger News

The White House

WND

Go to top

Political Commentary
Home Page


All Skills Are Learned
and the Method Is Key


The Foundations
of Freedom


Everyone is Smart but Trump

Climate Change
A Political Tool


Politics Trumps Economics Redux

Who Are the Good Guys?

Slavery Today!

Justice Clarence Thomas and the Lost Constitution

Politics Trumps Economics

The World's Second Constitution

Why America is Great

President Trump
in pictures


US stocks a better buy

Economic Arteries

The Left against
the First Amendment


Is a Stock-Market
Bubble Coming?


Individual Rights
States' Powers


Thanksgiving Toast
to the Old Breed


Honoring
George Washington


Business As Usual
at the White House


Patriotism

Who Gets To Decide?

America Rebounds!

The Trump Economic
Paradigm Change


What's wrong
with the EU


The Trump Presidency

The Election -
What Happened?
First Monday speech
5 December 2016


Mike Rowe on
Burning the Flag


Socialism means
giving your freedom
to the government


Second Amendment

Responsibility

This is Hillary

Where We Live

Honorable Politicians

Education

Citizen Politicians

So You Want Socialism?

Authorized Not Imposed

Against Rights and Freedom

Sustainability
vs. America


Speech to County GOP

The Economy

Being America

The Individual
vs. Statism


To-Do List

Unite or Die

Lost Trust

Quotable Quotes

Go to top


"Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it."

Three years after the U.S. Constitution came into force, the "Constitution of 3 May 1791" was put into effect by the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, a dual monarchy.   It "is generally considered Europe’s first, and the world’s second, modern written constitution, after the United States Constitution that had come into force in 1789."

If there were any doubts of the ability of the U.S. Constitution to survive – and in Europe there certainly were – the consequences for the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth were a huge part of the reasons.

Their constitution, like that of the U.S., created a republic (albeit, a monarchic republic) "with a clear division of executive, legislative, and judiciary powers."   Granted that there are now more written constitutions in Europe, but that separation of powers is something the rest of Europe lacks, for the most part, down to the present day, with the leading member of parliaments (by whatever name) being the Prime Minister (and the anachronistic king or queen being reduced to a token figurehead).

The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth had been a major European power a century earlier, and in 1791 was still the biggest country in Europe.   But its constitution – and the country itself – lasted only 19 months.

Why?   Because "the Commonwealth’s neighbors reacted with hostility to the adoption of the Constitution."   In other words, the idea of a constitutionally-limited government was something that, among others, Prussia’s King Frederick William II and Imperial Russia’s Czar Catherine "the Great" absolutely did not want to see infecting their own populations; the Commonwealth, for their sakes, could not be tolerated.   It had to fail.

As happened in France, The ideas promulgated in the Commonwealth included those most dangerous ones, of liberty, freedom, and individual rights, learned while helping the Americans fight their Revolutionary War against the British. Those ideas were spread by returning soldiers when they arrived back to their native homes.   As a direct result, France was then embroiled in its own Revolution.   To have a similar event in Europe’s largest country could not be allowed to happen.

And so they made sure not only that the Constitution of 3 May 1791 failed, but that the country itself was eradicated.   Poland and Lithuania were annexed into Russia, ending their freedoms, and ceased to be countries at all, for 130 years, until after World War I.

Keep in mind the subsequent events: the return of Lithuanian sovereignty in 1918 was subsequently ended after only two decades, with annexation by the Soviet Union during World War II.

Polish sovereignty returned in 1918, only to be overrun two decades later by the Germans in 1939, starting World War II and on their way to invading Russia.   Russia subsequently ran rough-shod over everything and everybody, with the vicious level of plunder, rapine, and destruction usually associated with barbaric savages (which the Soviet army commanders encouraged of their illiterate mid-Asian soldiers), all the way back to Berlin and beyond, until they met the Allied forces advancing from the west.

"East Germany" and Poland, along with others, became Communist puppet states of the Soviet Union.   Lithuania became a part of the Soviet Union, without any pretense of sovereignty.

Poland and Lithuania only regained their sovereignty in 1990, with the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Two hundred years of domination by foreign dictatorships (czars and communists) ended only three decades ago.   No wonder that both countries (and the rest of ex-Communist puppets in eastern Europe) are justifiably somewhat protective of their sovereignty, and do not casually let the new European Union bureaucratic-dictatorship take that from them.

And the worldwide efforts of socialists against freedom and individual rights continue, even within the U.S.

"Just because you do not take an interest in politics does not mean that politics will not take an interest in you." – Pericles

All quoted text is taken from this Wikipedia article
        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_3_May_1791

See also this about Lithuania,
        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithuania

For more on my thoughts on the nature of the European Union,
        see     http://www.scottcrosby.info/scottschoice.us/Choices/death-by-eu.html
        and     http://www.scottcrosby.info/scottschoice.us/Choices/eu_news.html

See these on the inherent, inevitable destructiveness of socialism,
        http://www.scottcrosby.info/scottschoice.us/Choices/socialism.html
        http://www.scottcrosby.info/scottschoice.us/Choices/who-decides.html
        http://www.scottcrosby.info/scottschoice.us/Choices/soyouwantsocialism.html

See this for the most frequent means in current use for justifying the erosion of personal freedom,
        http://weather.scottcrosby.info/climate.html

Learn from history, or repeat it,

--   Scott Crosby
      12 May 2019

Go to top